Most viral mutations have a limited impact on the viruses’ ability to infect, replicate, escape host immunity, and transmit; however, certain mutations can give a viral strain a competitive advantage and, through natural selection, give it the ability to become dominant. Many mutations observed in SARS-CoV-2 variants are found within the RBD or the N-terminal domain of the S protein, which alters the three dimensional structure of the S protein. Not only can these changes affect the transmission abilities of the virus, but it can also allow it to better escape the immune response, such as from neutralising antibodies either elicited through vaccine administration or natural infection.
The SARS-CoV-2 virus has mutated numerous times, with estimates suggesting that circulating lineages acquire nucleotide mutations at rates of around one to two mutations per month.71 The current method of identifying variants relies on the use of genomic testing such as whole genome sequencing, partial S gene sequencing, or assays based on nucleic acid amplification.72 The aspects of different variants that most people experience, however, is the clinical symptoms they inflict. Certain variants (eg, alpha, delta) induce a greater risk of severe disease and death,73 while others (eg, omicron) are more likely to induce milder symptom.74 75 Moreover, individual symptoms can differ between variants. For example, the gamma variant is associated inflicting anosmia and dysgeusia,76 which is less commonly seen in omicron infections. Moving forward, the clinical themes and symptoms associated with emerging variants should be elucidated rapidly so that the public and healthcare professionals can rapidly identify possible cases of covid-19.
WHO has tracked and monitored SARS-CoV-2 variants since the covid-19 pandemic began to identify variants of concern. As of 25 January 2022, WHO reported five variants of concern, two variants of interest, and three variants under monitoring (table 1).3 Here, we report studies that compare SARS-CoV-2 variants to the primary virus strain. The primary strain is the strain of the virus that first emerged in Wuhan, China at the end of 2019 and spread around the world in the first wave of infections, which is often also referred to as the Wuhan-Hu-1, B.1, or wildtype strain.
Variants of concern
Alpha variant B.1.1.7
The alpha SARS-CoV-2 variant of the B.1.1.7 lineage was first documented in the UK in September 2020 and classified as a variant of concern on 18 December 2020.3 77 This variant contains S protein mutations that have potential biological effects. Firstly, the S protein residue 501, a key contact residue within the RBD, forms a portion of the binding loop in the contact region of the ACE2 receptor, forms a hydrogen bond with the Y41 residue of the ACE2 receptor, and stabilises the ACE2 K353 residue.65 78 79 The alpha variant has an N501Y mutation, which increases the binding affinity of the RBD to the ACE2 receptor.80 Next, the P681H mutation contained within the alpha variant is located immediately adjacent to the 682-685 furin cleavage site, at the interface of the S1 and S2 domains.81 The S1/S2 furin cleavage site prompts entry into respiratory epithelial cells and partly determines the transmissibility of the virus,82–84 while the P681H mutation makes the furin cleavage site less acidic, meaning it is more effectively recognised and cleaved.85 86 Alpha also contains a D614G mutation, located within the S1/S2 furin cleavage site, which increases SARS-CoV-2 binding affinity to the ACE2 receptor and increases infectivity.87 Other mutations within the alpha variant enhance the ability of the virus to escape antibody detection, such as the two amino acid deletion at sites 69-70 in the N-terminal domain of the S protein,88 89 while other mutations show limited or no effects.90 In February 2021, viruses of the B.1.1.7 lineage with the added S protein mutation E484K were identified, which could have threatened vaccine effectiveness owing to the mutation conferring an increased resistance to neutralising vaccine elicited and monoclonal antibodies.91 This mutation had limited effects, however, and variants containing it failed to dominate.
Epidemiological studies have explored the alpha variant, with a case-control study of 27 633 respiratory samples originating from 20 primary care centres in Madrid, Spain, finding that the probability of admission to an intensive care unit was twice as high in patients infected with the alpha variant compared with those infected with the primary strain.92 Furthermore, this variant became the dominant strain within four months, and led to an increase in disease burden as a result.92
Meanwhile in Cannes, France, infection with the alpha variant was associated with a 3.8-fold higher risk of transfer to intensive care or death compared with the primary strain, as determined through a retrospective cohort study of 158 patients with covid-19.93 A large retrospective cohort study including a total of 476 973 participants found that, during the third covid-19 wave in Canada, where 91% of infections were caused by the alpha variant, the risk of both hospital admission (adjusted odds ratio 1.57) and death (1.52) was higher than primary strain infections.94 Overall, the alpha variant was about 50-70% more transmissible and was associated with a 30-60% increased risk of hospital admission and death compared with the primary strain.95–100
The alpha variant was found to have a minimal impact on the effectiveness of current vaccines,101 102 while the risk of reinfection remained similar for this variant as with previous ones.103 On 3 September 2021, the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC) reclassified the alpha, and the alpha +E484K mutation variants from a variant of concern to a de-escalated variant.104
Beta variant B.1.351
The beta SARS-CoV-2 variant, of the B.1.351 lineage, was first documented in South Africa in May 2020.3 This variant contains five S protein mutations of interest: N501Y, E484K, D614G, K417N, and A701V. Like the alpha variant, the beta variant contains the mutations N501Y, E484K, and D614G, which increase ACE2 receptor binding affinity,80 87 increase virulence,105 and enhance resistance to neutralising antibodies.91 106 The K417 residue of the SARS-CoV-2 S protein interacts with the D30 residue of the ACE2 receptor, forming a salt bridge across the central contact region,65 78 although the K417N mutation appears to have a limited impact on ACE2 receptor binding.80 The A701V mutation is located close to the furin cleavage site but has a minimal impact on transmissibility or antibody resistance.101
In a genomic and epidemiological study, researchers concluded that the beta SARS-CoV-2 variant had a selective advantage over previous variants from its increased transmissibility and immune escape abilities,107 108 whereas the E484K/N501K mutations enhanced the binding affinity of the beta variant and, hence, increased its transmissibility.109 A retrospective cohort study of 22 068 participants found that infection with the beta variant was associated with an increased risk of hospital admission compared with an infection with a non-variant of concern (hazard ratio 2.30).100 Overall, the beta variant is about 25-50% more transmissible, is associated with a possible increase in risk of hospital mortality, and has enhanced resistance to antibody neutralisation compared with previous variants.107 108 110
Gamma variant P.1
The gamma variant is of the P.1 lineage and was first reported in November 2020 from travellers returning to Japan from Brazil, and was later discovered in Brazil.3 111 This variant contains the following S protein mutations of interest: K417T, E484K, N501Y, D614G, and H655Y.104 As mentioned, the N501Y and D614G mutations increase both ACE2 receptor binding affinity and infectivity of the virus.80 87 The N501Y, K417N/T, and E484K mutation trinity, meanwhile, is shared by both gamma and beta variants, and is associated with enhanced infectivity and lethality compared with the N501Y mutation alone, possibly from tighter binding of the S protein to the ACE2 receptor due to increased electrostatic contribution.112 The gamma variant also includes the H655Y mutation, which was found to provide enhanced viral escape abilities from multiple human monoclonal antibodies in vitro.113
The gamma variant is associated with heightened transmissibility,109 110 114 with one study concluding that it possesses a 1.7-fold to 2.4-fold increased transmissibility compared with previous variants.115 Additionally, the wave of infections caused by the gamma variant in Brazil was associated with a 13% increase in death rate compared with the previous wave, suggesting the greater virulence held by the gamma variant than by previous viral strains.116
A surveillance study from seven European countries concluded that the gamma variant was associated with a higher risk of admission to hospital (adjusted odds ratio 2.6) and intensive care (2.2) when compared with cases of non-variants of concern.117 In Manaus, Brazil, the resurgence of covid-19, despite high seroprevalence, suggested that the gamma variant had a moderate resistance to neutralising antibodies,118 however, the variant has been shown to be significantly less resistant to neutralising antibodies than other variants, including the beta variant.119
Delta variant B.1.617.2
The delta variant, from the B.1.617.2 lineage, was first documented in India in October 2020 and was classified as a variant of concern on 11 May 2021.3 The S protein mutations of interest P681R and D614G are also located in the delta variant104 and similarly affect its ACE2 receptor binding affinity and transmissibility.106 120 121 Unlike the E484K mutation seen in previous variants, the delta variant contains the E484Q mutation that, along with a L452R mutation also located within the RBD, causes significantly higher affinity for the ACE2 receptor than the primary strain or the E484K mutation alone.122 The L452R mutation alone results in greater RBD-ACE2 receptor binding affinity and enhanced escape from neutralising antibodies.123 124 Lastly, the delta variant contains the T478K mutation, located on the interface between the S protein and the ACE2 receptor when bound, which increases the electrostatic potential of the S protein and enhances binding affinity.125
The delta variant quickly became the dominant variant in the UK,126 US,127 Europe, and around the world.128 The mutations present in the delta variant enhanced the transmissibility of the virus as a result of increased binding affinity to the ACE2 receptor.109 The reproduction number of the delta variant is estimated to be 97% greater than that of non-variants of concern or non-variants of interest, and about three times that of the alpha, beta, and gamma variants.110 This increased reproductivity highlights the delta variant's competitive advantage over earlier ones and how it rapidly became the dominant strain globally. The fast replication rate of delta probably contributes to its increased transmissibility compared with the alpha, beta, and gamma variants. In a cohort study consisting of 167 infections, the delta variant could be detected by polymerase chain reaction within the first four days from exposure, whereas non-delta covid-19 infections could be detected after only six days.129 Furthermore, people infected with the delta variant were found to have significantly higher viral loads than people infected with other strains,129 including the beta variant.130 The delta variant is also thought to better escape neutralisation, with the frequency of post-vaccination infections much higher for the delta variant than infections with the primary strain in India,131 and blood serum samples from individuals who had received one dose of a covid-19 vaccine showing minimal neutralisation of the delta variant.132
The delta variant is also associated with an increased disease severity. In Scotland, infection with the delta variant was associated with an increased risk of hospital admission (hazard ratio 1.85) compared with infection with the alpha variant.133 Compared with infections involving non-variants of concern, North American retrospective cohort studies showed that infection with the delta variant was associated with a 108%134 or hazard ratio of 2.28 (95% confidence interval 1.56-3.34) 100 increased risk of hospital admission, a 234% increased risk for admission to intensive care, and a 132% increased risk of death.134 Lastly, in a cross sectional study of 6238 individuals infected with the delta variant and 3262 infected with the primary strain in India, researchers found that the risk of death was around 1.8 times higher for delta infections, while the delta variant also infected and induced symptoms in a greater proportion of younger people (age 0-19 years) than did the primary strain.131
Omicron variant B.1.1.529
The omicron variant is of the B.1.1.529 lineage and was first discovered in November 2021 in South Africa and Botswana before being detected in multiple countries and classified as a variant of concern on 26 November 2021.3 This variant contains over 30 S protein mutations,104 23 of which have been previously identified, including K417N, T478K, E484A, D614G, H655Y, P681H, and N501Y.135 Fifteen omicron mutations are contained within the RBD,17 providing the variant with a substantially enhanced binding affinity to the ACE2 receptor.135 136 In addition, various single mutations in the RBD of the omicron variant impair the effectiveness of neutralising antibodies, including K417N, N440K, G446S, E484A, Q493K, G496S, G339D, S371L, and S375F.17
The emergence of omicron has been followed by a surge of infections worldwide. Early data from South Africa have indicated that the proportion of covid-19 infections caused by the omicron variant rose from 3% in early October 2021 to 98% by early December 2021.137 In late December 2021, meanwhile, the doubling time for the number of omicron infections was between two and three in the UK, US, and much of Europe,138 139 highlighting the transmissibility of this variant. The mutations in the omicron variant that enhance its binding affinity135 136 and ability to escape neutralising antibodies17 probably drove its rapid spread, as did its fast replication rate, which is around 70 times faster than the delta and primary strains.140 The reinfection rate of the omicron variant has also been found to be more than ten times higher than that of previous variants in studies from Scotland141 and South Africa.142
The omicron variant has extensive but incomplete escape abilities from naturally acquired and vaccine induced immunity.143 144 Compared with the delta variant, the omicron variant needs around a 10-fold increased antibody titre to be neutralised, after vaccination with either the ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 (Oxford-AstraZeneca) or BNT162b2 (Pfizer-BioNTech) vaccines.145 Indeed, blood serum from individuals who had received two doses of the BNT162b2 vaccine showed more than a 25-fold reduction in neutralising antibody titres against the omicron variant compared with the primary strain.146 T cell responses to the omicron variant could remain intact, however. Data from one preprint study indicated that 70-80% of the T cell response targeting the S protein was maintained in those individuals vaccinated or with previous infection, while the magnitude of T cells cross reacting with the omicron variant was similar to that of both delta and beta variants.147 Furthermore, data from Pfizer-BioNtech revealed that 80% of the epitopes in the omicron variant S protein that are recognised by CD8 T cells were not affected by the variant’s mutations, after two doses of the vaccine.146 T cell responses induced from vaccination or prior infection could, therefore, provide some protection from severe disease.
Recent real world evidence has implied that omicron infection is milder in severity than previous variants. In an early South African analysis, the risk of hospital admission (adjusted odds ratio 0.2) was lower for omicron infections than for non-omicron infections,137 while omicron infected individuals had a lower risk of severe disease than delta infected individuals (0.3).137 In December 2021 in England, omicron infections were found to induce a greatly reduced risk of hospital admission or presentation for emergency care than delta infections.74 75 The decreased disease severity inflicted by the omicron variant could be due to its reduced capacity for replication in lung tissue, which was found to be more than 10 times less in lung tissue than the delta variant.140 Concordantly, the S protein of the omicron variant is less efficient at cleaving the ACE2 receptor and entering cells of lung organoids,145 and is also less able to cause fusion between lung cells than the S protein of the delta variant,145 which is often observed in severe covid-19. The reduction in replication within the lungs, and the preservation of T cell responses probably contribute to the milder disease exerted by the omicron variant.
The original Omicron variant is referred to as BA.1, due to the detection of several sublineages of the variant in circulation. While the emergence of BA.1 coincided with a wave of covid-19 infections around the world due to its higher transmissibility and increased risk of reinfection than previous variants,148 sublineages BA.2 and BA.3 are also circulating, with BA.2 now responsible for an increasing number of the reported cases.149 The current data remains limited, however, the UK Health Security Agency report that BA.2 has an increased growth rate compared to BA.1 although this report did not find any evidence of a difference in vaccine effectiveness between the two sublineages of the Omicron variant.150 Indeed, the REACT-1 study of covid-19 transmission concluded that BA.2 had a daily growth rate additive advantage of 0.4 compared to BA.1.151 The risk of hospitalisation does not seem to be higher for BA.2 infection in comparison to BA.1, however.152 Emerging sublineages of the Omicron variant will be required to be monitored and reported upon for the foreseeable the future.
Although the omicron variant seems to manifest in mild disease, high infection numbers could still result in high rates of hospital admission and death in those individuals vulnerable to the virus. Omicron case numbers could be beginning to peak, however. In South Africa, a 29.7% decrease in weekly covid-19 infections were reported in the week ending 25 December 2021, compared with the previous week, and the omicron wave is said to have passed.153 Concerningly, global case numbers continue to rise rapidly154 and many countries will continue to feel the pressure exerted by the wave of omicron infections.
Variants of interest
Lambda variant C.37
The lambda variant, of the C.37 lineage, was first documented in Peru in December 2020 and was designated as a variant of interest on 14 June 2021.3 This variant contains the S protein mutations D614G, L452Q, and F490S.104 The L452Q mutation, located within the RBD, enhances binding affinity to the ACE2 receptor and increases the infectivity of the lambda variant,155 while, together L452Q and F490S, increasing the variant's resistance to vaccine elicited antibody neutralisation.155 Furthermore, F490S was identified as being a high risk mutation for enhancing abilities to escape neutralisation.155
Infectivity of the lambda variant could be higher than that of the alpha, gamma, and other D614G containing variants,156 suggesting that lambda could spread more rapidly and effectively. Additionally, compared with the primary SARS-CoV-2 virus, antibody neutralisation was found to decrease by 3.05-fold for the lambda variant, higher than that for the gamma (2.33-fold) and alpha (2.03-fold) variants.156 However, findings from a preprint study suggest that the lambda variant can be neutralised by monoclonal antibodies, and that current vaccines are protective against this variant.155
Mu variant B.1.621
The mu variant, from the B.1.621 lineage, was first documented in Columbia in January 2021 before receiving designation as a variant of interest on 30 August 2021.3 This variant contains the S protein mutations E484K, N501Y, D614G, and P681H.104 Mu also contains the S protein mutation R346K, located within the RBD,104 157 which can induce large, binding, free energy changes that disrupt the binding of antibodies to the S protein and enhance the ability of the variant to escape neutralisation.158 As discussed, the E484K, N501Y, D614G, and P681H mutations have been shown to increase transmissibility80 85 87 105 109 112 120 121 and neutralisation escape,91 106 suggesting that the mu variant is likely to be more infectious than the primary strain.
Although the lambda and mu variants have been outcompeted by the delta and now omicron variants, the development and spread of these variants of interest will need to be closely monitored and studied to appreciate their pathogenicity, transmissibility, and virulence.